My Boyfriend Invited Me on a Surprise Valentines Day Date — It Turned Into a Nightmare I Never Saw Coming

When I met someone I thought was perfect, I imagined us being happy for a long time after dating for a few months. That was until he pulled a stunt that made me reconsider his role in my life. But now, Im not sure if I made the right choice.

I used to be a big believer in love. I even thought Valentines Day was about love, too. But I also believed the special day was about connection and celebrating something real between two people.

Then came Andrew, who changed it all.

A happy man | Source: Midjourney

Andrew and I had been dating for only three months, but in that short time, he had become everything I thought I wanted! He was charming, smart, and successful!

Before getting into other aspects of our relationship, let me fill you in on how we came to be.

I was 29, and my boyfriend, who was two years older, met me under the strangest of circumstances. One day, he had an unfortunate accident—he tripped in his office, landing palm-first onto a pair of scissors sticking out of a cup on his desk!

A man holding his injured hand | Source: Midjourney

As an intern, I was the one to patch him up. He grinned through the pain, cracking self-deprecating jokes, and by the time I finished stitching him up, he had already asked for my number!

I was in medical school and was the intern on duty at the hospital where he was treated. I had the difficult task of stitching him up while he winced in pain but he still managed to delight me by cracking self-deprecating jokes.

A woman helping a patient | Source: Midjourney

Against my better judgment, I allowed him to flirt, and we exchanged numbers. Eventually, one thing led to another, and we started having coffee dates after my grueling hospital shifts.

I thought he was a wonderful man. We spoke about everything under the sun, including our childhood dreams and future ambitions. I opened up about how I was drowning in debt, barely scraping by in medical school in my pursuit to become a doctor and save lives.

A student at school | Source: Midjourney

But Andrew? He already had made it. He worked at a major tech company, pulling in six figures, and lived like money would never be a problem! Ironically, his parents were both doctors. They had wanted him to follow in their footsteps, but he rebelled, choosing coding over scalpels.

They cut him off and disowned him for it. Weirdly, I think he saw me as proof that his decision had been right. In hindsight, maybe thats why he latched onto me so quickly—I was the struggling doctor he had avoided becoming.

A happy couple | Source: Midjourney

From the start of our relationship, I insisted on splitting everything when we went out. It wasnt that I had extra money to burn—it was that I refused to be seen as someone who was “dating him for his wealth.” He always seemed amused by it, laughing and saying, “Youre different from most girls.”

I should have paid more attention to the way he said that.

Then came Valentines Day.

A couple on a date | Source: Midjourney

A week before, he teased me, grinning over the rim of his coffee cup. “I have something special planned for Valentines Day.”

I hesitated. “Where are we going? You know I cant afford anything fancy right now. Please dont forget that I need to know the cost upfront, cause you know Im living paycheck to paycheck, and extravagant dates arent in my budget.”

“Dont worry about it, its a surprise,” he said, waving me off. “Just trust me.”

I should have known better.

A unsure woman on a date | Source: Midjourney

That night, he showed up in an Uber Black, not his car.

I frowned. “Did something happen to your car?”

“Nah,” he said, smoothing his tie. “Wanted to go all out for tonight.”

That nervous feeling in my stomach intensified, but I pushed it down.

Then we pulled up to one of the most expensive restaurants in the city—the kind where the menus dont have prices because if you need to ask, you cant afford it!

A fancy restaurant | Source: Midjourney

I turned to him the second we stepped inside. “Andrew, I really—”

“Relax,” he said, guiding me toward our table. “Ive got this.”

He looked in his element when he ordered everything—fine wine, lobster, oysters, and risotto with white truffles! I barely touched my food, only eating a little here and there. Something felt off, and I kept thinking about being judged as a gold digger.

An uncomfortable woman on a date | Source: Midjourney

Andrew was unusually giddy, his phone propped up on the table, recording bits and pieces of our date. He kept grinning at the camera, saying things like, “Special night with my girl,” and, “Man, she really knows how to eat,” even though I didnt eat much.

I laughed nervously, trying to ignore the pit forming in my stomach. But I must admit, the little I did eat that night tasted more delicious than anything I had ever eaten in my life! The food was amazing, and our outing felt like something out of a movie!

A woman enjoying her food | Source: Midjourney

Then the check came.

$3,180!

I felt the blood drain from my face.

Before I could even process it, Andrew picked up his phone and flipped the camera toward me.

“So, babe,” he said, his grin widening. “Were splitting this, right?”

For a second, I thought I had misheard him.

I gave a small, uneasy laugh. “You told me not to worry about money tonight. You said youd take care of everything, remember?” I replied, looking shocked, confused, and embarrassed.

My worst nightmare was about to become a reality—I was going to be branded a gold digger!

A shocked woman | Source: Midjourney

“Yeah, but come on,” he snorted. “You ate, didnt you?”

My heart started pounding. “Andrew, you know I dont have this kind of money.”

“You dont?” His voice was light and playful. “Well, I guess you shouldve thought about that before you went in on all this food.”

I felt eyes on me. The restaurant had gone quiet. People were watching. The waiter stood frozen, holding the bill.

Then Andrew turned the camera toward himself and did something I will never forget or forgive.

A man recording himself | Source: Midjourney

“Mom, Dad, you always said I shouldve been a doctor,” he said, chuckling as he turned the camera between us. “Well, heres what life wouldve been like if I had—dating someone who cant even afford her own dinner!”

I couldnt move. I could barely breathe.

He turned off the camera, casually tossed his credit card onto the bill, and smirked at the stunned waiter.

Then something inside me finally snapped!

A shocked woman | Source: Midjourney

I stood up so fast that my chair nearly tipped over! The heat of humiliation burned through my skin, but more than that, I felt anger! Andrew was still grinning, still holding his phone, but when I grabbed my coat and turned away, his smirk faltered.

“Wait, babe, where are you going?!” he asked, looking confused.

I didnt answer. I ran and pushed through the restaurant doors, barely registering the cold night air as I flagged down a taxi with shaking hands and tears in my eyes!

A woman outside about to catch a taxi | Source: Mdijourney

My phone buzzed in my lap the entire ride home. Andrew kept calling over and over again, and when he realized I wasnt going to answer, the texts started. Just as I was about to read them, my driver piped up.

“Uh, maam, are you okay? Do you need anything?”

“Hey, yes, so sorry about this. I just need some peace and quiet. Ill be fine, thank you,” I replied sniffling softly, hoping hed get the hint and leave me alone.

A woman talking to her cab driver | Source: Midjourney

The driver nodded through his rearview mirror and focused on the road. I took the opportunity to glance at my phone.

It was a joke. A prank. Youre overreacting. I was just proving a point to my parents. I didnt mean it. Please dont be mad. Answer me…

I couldnt believe him! He really thought that explanation was good enough to wipe away the pain of how hed just humiliated me. I decided to ignore him before blocking his number.

A woman using her phone | Source: Midjourney

I spent that night staring at the ceiling, the weight of everything pressing down on me. I couldnt get over the betrayal, the embarrassment, and the realization that I had never really known him at all.

AdvertisementRead alsoStoriesI Posted a Picture of My Partner and Me on Facebook for the First Time & Immediately Got a Message: You Must Run from Him. Now

December 16, 2024

StoriesMy Neighbor Knocked on My Door with Tears in Her Eyes – Your Husband Is a Monster, She Cried

December 05, 2024

StoriesI Married a Janitor to Spite My Wealthy Dad — When My Dad Came to Speak with My Husband, He Fell to His Knees at His Words

December 16, 2024

But the worst part?

The next night, he showed up on my doorstep! He kept calling my name and knocking like a policeman who was certain the criminal he was looking for was hiding inside!

A man knocking on a door | Source: Midjourney

Since he wasnt quitting or getting the message, I decided to confront him. I opened the door just enough to look him straight in the eyes and threatened, “If you come near me again, Ill file a restraining order.”

Thats when his smirk finally disappeared, and he left.

I sat in my tiny apartment, staring at my phone, unable to stop thinking about what had happened. Wanting some sort of support, I reached out to my best friend, Kara, but her response left me more confused.

An upset woman on a call | Source: Midjourney

“Are you sure you want to dump him over this? Dont you want to reconsider?” she asked me over the phone.

I was stunned by her question. “He humiliated me.”

She sighed. “Yeah, but he paid in the end, didnt he? It was just a joke. Hes rich, Jess. Maybe he was trying to impress his parents or something.”

I let out a bitter laugh. “Wealth doesnt make someone a good person.”

Kara replied, “No, but it makes life a lot easier.”

But inside, I wasnt so sure.

What do you think, dear reader? Am I wrong?

A confused woman | Source: Midjourney

While you mull that one over, heres another one about Valentines Day. Mirandas mother made sacrifices to take care of her child when she got pregnant at 18. But before Valentines Day arrived, Mirandas mother heard her plotting to make her cancel her date to babysit. That was a big mistake that taught the young mother of one a valuable lesson.

This work is inspired by real events and people, but it has been fictionalized for creative purposes. Names, characters, and details have been changed to protect privacy and enhance the narrative. Any resemblance to actual persons, living or dead, or actual events is purely coincidental and not intended by the author.

The author and publisher make no claims to the accuracy of events or the portrayal of characters and are not liable for any misinterpretation. This story is provided “as is,” and any opinions expressed are those of the characters and do not reflect the views of the author or publisher.